• Home
  • About
    • Brand College Consulting
    • Jolyn Brand
  • Press and Awards
  • Client Testimonials
  • Make a Payment
  • Contact

Brand College Consulting

College assistance for families

Student Dashboard

Schedule an Appointment

  • College Admissions
    • College Consulting
    • College Consulting Registration Form
  • Blog
  • Pro Bono Advising
  • College Students

Turning the Tide- A Change in College Admissions?

January 21, 2016 By Jolyn Brand

Parents, teachers, college professionals, and students know the positive and negative effects of college admissions: from the joy of getting acceptances, to the intense pressure in applying, to the unending questions from well-meaning friends and family. Many professionals in the higher education field are also aware of the mental and stressed kidemotional stress placed on students and the advantage of more affluent students from more well-resourced schools. But, are  times changing? Are colleges willing to change the criteria for college admissions? Maybe.

More than 80 college admissions professionals, high school counselors, and stakeholders have endorsed a new college admissions report released this week. The report, entitled Turning the Tide: Inspiring Concern for Others and the Common Good Through College Admissions, aims to address these issues.  The report was released during a New York City panel and is supposed to lay out “a blueprint for addressing three of the most intractable challenges facing college applicants today: excessive academic performance pressure, the emphasis on personal achievement over good citizenship, and the uneven opportunities available to students of varying income levels and backgrounds”.

The report was also endorsed by the Board of Directors of the Coalition for Access, Affordability, and Success. In September, the Coalition announced its intention to make the college admissions process more equitable by introducing a new application intended to reduce student stress. However, many in the college admissions world, including myself, were troubled by the Coalition’s goals and steps toward that goal. The Coalition platform would serve as an application website and source of information to those colleges and its prospective students, but they also boast of a “digital locker” for students to store information and creative works starting in 9th grade. It’s easy to see how affluent families will interpret this as another task on their to-do list for college admissions, while students with poorly-resourced schools and counselors, might not even hear about it.

Many expressed concern that the Coalition is simply another step to make the elite even more so. Jon Boeckenstedt, the associate vice president of enrollment management and marketing at DePaul University in Chicago, said “A group of America’s most high-profile private colleges, already obsessed with prestige, are attempting to grab more,” in The Washington Post. He added that they were “making hollow promises to low-income kids they could already serve if they really wanted to.”

 

Possible Changes and Recommendations for College Admissions

The Turning the Tide Report had many suggested changes, along with specific recommendations for each intended for college applications and students. These recommendations are just that: recommendations. They might not actually take effect, but parents, students, and counselors should pay attention for a possible shift in focus which would affect high school students applying in the coming years.

Focus #1– “Promote meaningful contributions to others, community service, and engagement with the public good”

Recommendations:student contr to others

  1. Meaningful, consistent community service
  2. College action that takes on challenges in the community
  3. Authentic experiences with diversity
  4. Service that develops gratitude and a sense of responsibility for the future

 

Focus #2-“Emphasize authentic engagement over personal achievement”

“Yes, we want students who have achieved in and out of the classroom, but we are also looking for things that are harder to quantify: authentic intellectual engagement, a concern for others and the common good.” said Yale Dean of Undergraduate Admissions Jeremiah Quinlan.

Recommendations:

  1. Contributions to one’s family

“These students may be caring for a sick relative, supervising a younger sibling, helping to run a household or working after school to support their families. Often students can’t undertake conventional high school extracurricular activities and community involvement because of these important obligations. At the same time, these family responsibilities themselves are often building blocks of ethical character.”

  1. Student’s awareness and contribution to others

“The report highlights a common misconception that volunteering for certain high-profile causes or traveling to exotic countries will make an application stand out. It will, but for the wrong reasons: namely that it looks inauthentic”.

Focus #3– Level the playing field for economically diverse students and reduce excessive high achieving students graduateachievement pressure

Recommendations:

  1. Prioritize quality, not quantity of extracurricular activities
  2. Awareness of overloading of AP/IB courses

Colleges are not stating that students don’t need to take AP courses. They are stating that there is no need to overburden yourself with excessive amounts of AP or IB courses. Instead of an AP course in every subject for all years, students can focus on more in-depth knowledge and practice in just a few subjects.

  1. Discourage over-coaching

Over-coaching can take many forms: from parents who write or overly “assist” with college essays to high school counselors who suggest students take classes that are good on applications but not of interest, to college consultants who tell students what to write about or overly ‘package’ students.

  1. Options for reducing test pressure

High scores on the SAT or ACT correlate with high family income, in part because performance on these tests can be improved with the special classes and private tutoring that money buys. Some colleges are going test-optional, but all students should be reminded that taking a standardized test more than twice is not recommended.

  1. Expand perceptions of “good” colleges and instead focus on “best fit” for students

good colleges

Effects and Responses from Colleges

Some colleges are already taking notice and making changes based on the report:

Yale University said they will add a question to the Yale application asking students to “reflect on engagement with and contribution to their family, community and/or the public good,” and would also advocate for more flexibility in the Common and Coalition Applications so that schools can customize how students discuss extracurricular activities in their applications.

The University of Virginia is also in agreement with the report. “We support Turning the Tide because we philosophically agree with many of the principal points in the document, [like] promoting, encouraging, and developing good citizenship, strong character, personal responsibility, [and] civic engagement in high school students,” says Gregory Roberts, the school’s dean of admissions.

Stephen Farmer, at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, praised the report as consistent with his school’s desire “to be humbler and more alert to the many ways in which people can stake a claim on a place here.”

Conclusion

The conclusion is summed up well in Executive Summary of the report:

“As a rite of passage for many students and a major focus for many parents, the college admissions process is powerfully positioned to send different messages that help young people become more generous and humane in ways that benefit not only society but students themselves. Yet high school students often perceive colleges as simply valuing their achievements, not their responsibility for others and their communities. While some colleges have diligently sought to convey to applicants the importance of concern for others and the common good, many other colleges have not.”

Sources: Turning the Tide Report, Huffington Post, The Washington Post, and Yale Daily News

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Filed Under: Upcoming Events Tagged With: college admissions, college advice, college applications, college consultant, college counselor, college students, turning the tide

Contact Jolyn Brand

Brand College Consulting Dr. Jolyn Brand Independent Education Consultant Houston: (832) 910- 7990 Philadelphia: (215) 690-1160 You … [Read sticle...]

Press and Awards
Recent Articles

Google Reviews

Brand College Consulting
Brand College Consulting
5.0
Based on 5 reviews
powered by Google
review us on
Joel Delgado
Joel Delgado
16:37 27 Sep 19
Our experience with Jolly Brand was exceptional.
Jacob Gunter
Jacob Gunter
04:27 06 Jul 19
Shannon Robbins
Shannon Robbins
16:26 14 Apr 17
Our experience with Jolyn Brand was exceptional. She was very responsive to us and offered valuable guidance throughout the college preparation and application process. My daughter got in to all of the schools in which she applied, even her stretch school. We credit Jolyn with helping us to make sure her resume, application and essays were top notch.
Marylee Olson
Marylee Olson
00:29 08 Mar 17
Brand College Consulting was GREAT for our son! We met Ms. Brand when my son was in 7th grade! We saw her for an hour consult yearly to help him select his classes, plus a little algebra tutoring in high school. He was ahead of others course-wise and we were able to get 21 hours dual credit in high school, he made the Dean's List, Phi Theta Kappa, and Natl Society of High School Scholars. We are a family of Texas State Bobcats and it's very competitive now to get in but he did and we are thrilled! I recommend Ms. Brand and her services! Marylee Olson, Silverlake, Pearland (Dawson High School)
Chaplain Forever
Chaplain Forever
23:49 05 Oct 16
My youngest daughter attended tutorial services with Ms. Brand. Due to the exemplary, SAT preparation services, my daughter was accepted into several top colleges including the University of Houston, Texas State, Lamar University, and Sam Houston. As a college student, she received scholarships and has been on the Dean's list every semester. Ms. Brand instilled confidence in my daughter. I will be forever grateful.
See All Reviews
js_loader

Client Testimonials

avatarJolyn Brand is the subject matter expert on whom I rely for all things college-related. When I refer career counseling clients to her for college admissions consulting, I can be 100% confident about her knowledge of Texas colleges, her ability to be an educational advocate for prospective and current students, and her incredible level of professional customer service. She is one of those people who will always take a moment to answer a question or return an email and it is much appreciated by her colleagues and clients. I highly recommend her.

Janet Civitelli
Career Counselor/Vocational Psychologist
Read more››

About Jolyn Brand

Jolyn is a certified teacher who holds a Doctorate in Higher Education from Northeastern University. After years of experience teaching high school and college students, she began assisting with the college process. She's the founder of Brand College Consulting and works with families across the country virtually. A note from Jolyn: I started working with low-income high school students in … More...

Article Categories

  • ACT and SAT
  • Essays
  • FAQ's
  • Financial Aid
  • For Juniors
  • For Seniors
  • Grad Schools
  • Seminars
  • Testimonials
  • Upcoming Events

Recent Articles

  • Spring To Do List For Juniors
  • Timeline for Taking the SAT or ACT
  • Does the PSAT Matter? Should You Prepare?
  • Creating Your Student Resume for College Admissions
  • 10 Things to See and Do on a College Tour
  • Law School Applications Surge
  • After College Applications
  • Open House Days at Texas Colleges

Brand-College-Consulting-header-02.jpgDr. Jolyn Brand

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2025 | Brand College Consulting

 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d